TOA AN NHAN DAN THANH PHO SA DEC TiNH DONG THAP

CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM Doc lap - Tir do - Hanh phuc

Ban an so: 33/2024/HS-ST Ngay: 17-5-2024

NHAN DANH

NtfOC CONG HOA XA HOI CHU NGHIA VIET NAM • • •

TOA AN NHAN DAN THANH PHO SA DEC-TiNH DONG THAP

• - Thanh phan Hoi dong xet xu so’ tham gom cd:

9

Tham phan - Chii toa phien toa: Ong Dang Hoang Minh

Cac Hoi tham nhdn dan: Ong To Phu My va ong Nguyen Van Minh

• - Thu ky phien toa: Ba Huynh Hoang Linh - Thu ky Toa an nhan dan thanh pho Sa Dec, tinh Dong Thap.

• - Dai dien Vien kiem sat nhdn dan thanh pho Sa Dec tham gia phien toa: Ba Le Thi Thu Phuong - Kiem sat vien

Ngay 17 thang 5 nam 2024 tai Tru sb Toa an nhan dan thanh pho Sa Dec, tinh \                                                                9                                                                                                  9                                 r

Dong Thap xet xu so tham cong khai vu an hinh str so tham thu ly so 34/2024/TLST-HS ngay 23 thang 4 nam 2024 theo Quyet dinh dua vu an ra xet xu so 34/2024/QDXXST-HS ngay 06thang 5 nam 2024 doi vdi cac bi cao:

• 1. Ho va ten: Nguyen Van T (ten goi khac: Tl), sinh nam 1989 tai tinh An Giang; Noi cu tru: 707C, dirbng P, khom D, phubng M, thanh pho L, tinh An Giang; Nghe nghiep: Khong; Trinh do hoc van: 9/12; Dan toe: Kinh; Gidi tinh: Nam; Ton giao: Phat giao; Quoc tich: Viet Nam; Con ong: Tran Anh T2 va con ba Nguyen Thi P; Vo: Tran Thanh Anh T3, sinh nam 1992; Con: Co 05 con, Ion nhat sinh nam 2013, nho nhat sinh nam 2023; A, chi, em ruot: Co 02 ngubi, bi cao la con ut trong gia dinh; Tien an, tien sir: Khong; Tam giir: Ngay 09/01/2024; Tam giam: Ngay 12/01/2024. Hien dang bi tarn giam tai Nha tarn giir Cong an thanh pho S. (Co mat)

• 2. Ho va ten: Vo Ba K (ten goi khac: S), sinh nam: 1983 tai tinh An Giang; Noi cu tru: 604/16, khom D, phubng D, thanh pho L, tinh An Giang; Nghe nghiep: Lam thue; Trinh do hoc van: 3/12; Dan toe: Kinh; Gidi tinh: Nam; Ton giao: Khong; Quoc tich: Viet Nam; Con ong Vo Ba T4 (chet) va con ba Huynh Thi SI (chet); Vo, con: Chua co; Anh, chi, em: 04 ngubi, bi cao la con ut trong gia dinh; Tien str: Khong co; Tien an: Co 03 tien an, (1) Ban an hinh sir so tham so 24/HSST ngay 04/3/2005 cua Toa an nhan dan thanh pho Long Xuyen, tinh An Giang xu phat Vo Ba K muc an 03

a                       r                                                                                                                                                             9

nam 06 thang til ve toi “Tron klioi noi giam” (thuoc tnrbng hop tai pham nguy hiem).

Chua duoc xoa an tich. (2) Ban an hinli sir so tham so 56/2005/HSST ngay 20/5/2005 cua Tda an nhan dan thanh pho Long Xuyen, tinh An Giang xir phat Vo Ba K muc an 11 nam 06 thang til ve cac toi “Trom cip tai san”, “Co y gay thuong tich”, “Cirdp tai san” (thuoc trudng hop tai pham nguy hiem). Tong hop vdi hinh phat cua Ban an so 24/HSST ngay 04/3/2005 cua Tda an nhan dan thanh pho Long Xuyen, tinh An Giang, Vo Ba K phai chap hanh hinh phat chung la 15 nam tu. Doi vdi phan an phi, trach nhiem boi thuong dan sir, Chi cue Thi hanh an dan sir thanh pho Long Xuyen, r

tinh An Giang chua nhan duoc ban an do Tda an nhan dan thanh pho Long Xuyen, tinh An Giang chuyen giao, nen chua thu ly thi hanh doi vdi ban an nay. Chua duoc xoa an tich. (3) Ban an hinh sir so tham so 144/2007/HSST ngay 11/12/2007 cua Tda an nhan dan tinh An Giang xu phat Vo Ba K muc an 07 nam tir ve toi “Tron 9               9

klioi noi giam” (thuoc trudng hop tai pham nguy hiem). Tong hop vdi hinh phat cua Ban an so 56/2005/HSST ngay 20/5/2005 cua Toa an nhan dan thanh pho Long Xuyen, tinh An Giang, Vo Ba K phai chap hanh hinh phat chung la 22 nam tu. Chap hanh xong hinh phat tu ngay 03/5/2023. Chua duoc xoa an tich; Nhan than: Ban an hinh sir phuc tham so 3003/HSPT ngay 30/11/2000 cua Tda phuc tham tai thanh pho Ho Chi Minh xu phat Vo Ba K muc an 07 nam tir ve toi “Giet ngirdi” (pham toi thuoc r                                                    r

tnrdng hop rat nghiem trong). Chap hanh xong hinh phat tu ngay 14/8/2004. Thi hanh xong phan an phi ngay 22/6/2001 (Kliong tinh an tich do khi pham toi K chua du 16 tudi); Tam giu: Ngay 09/01/2024; Tam giam: Ngay 12/01/2024. Hien dang bi tarn giam tai Nha tarn giu Cong an thanh pho S. (Co mat)

• - Bi hai:

+ Anil Le Ngoc C, sinh nam 1976. Noi cu tru: So B, dudng H, Khom A, Phuong B, thanh pho S, tinh Dong Thap. (ving mat)

+ Anh Nguyen Le Duy T5, sinh nam 1993. Noi cu tru: So A, dudng N, phudng T, quan N, Thanh pho Can Tho. Cho d hien nay: So A, Nguyen Tnrdng T6, Khom A, Phudng A, thanh pho S, tinh Dong Thap. (ving mat)

+ Chi Nguyen Thanh T7, sinh nam 1995. Noi cir tru: So A, Nguyen Tnrdng T6, Khom A, Phudng A, thanh pho S, tinh Dong Thap. (vang mat)

• - Ngirdi lam chung:

+ Anh Dang Hieu H, sinh nam 1986. Noi cu tru: So A, Nguyen Truong T6, Khom A, Phudng A, thanh pho S, tinh Dong Thap. (vang mat)

+ Anh Do Thanh N, sinh nam 1976. Noi cu tru: To A, ap T, xa T, huyen G, tinh Kien Giang. (vang mat)

NOI DUNG VU AN:

• •

Theo cac tai lieu co trong ho so vu an va dien hien tai phien tda, noi dung vu an duoc tom tat nhu sau:

Ngay 08/01/2024, Vo Ba Kva Nguyen Van T dieu kliien xe mo to bien so 68P2- 7032 chb nhau di tir thanh pho L, tinh An Giang den thanh pho S, tinh Dong Thap. Khi di den kliu Trung tam thuong mai V thanh phd S, T phat hien Quan an gia dinh 168 toa lac dubng A, Khom D, Phuong A, thanh pho S (do anh Nguyen Le Duy T5 va chi Nguyen Thanh T7 lam chu) co khoa cong rao nhung ben trong khdng co ngubi trong giu. T nay sinh y dinh lay trom tai san trong quan, nen keu K dung xe lai, r                                 r                                                                                                                                                         \

T xuong xe di bo den trubc cong quan quan sat roi keu K dat xe len via he, dau b gan 9                                                                            9                             9

cbng va dung chb T. T treo len cbng rao thi cbng rao bi nghieng va phat ra am thanh nen T nhb K vin canh cong lai cho T treo vao ben trong.

T di den ban tiep tan cua quan, keo ngan tu lay trom diroc so tien 15.000 dong bo vao tui quan va nhin thay tren ban co 01 con heo dat mau hong, T cam len lac manh thi nghe thay am thanh co tien ben trong, nen T mang con heo dat den san r           \                    9

nude cua quan dap vb con heo lay tien va de vao bich nylon mau den nhat duoc b gan do. T quay lai ban tiep tan cua quan lay trom 01 bo tai nghe khong day nhan hieu AirPods Pro mau trang va 01 bo tai nghe khdng day nhan hieu Soundpeats mau den, 01 bich nylon mau den ben trong co khoang 35 goi thuoc la (gom nhieu nhan hieu), roi treo len cong rao ra ngoai. T dua bich nylon dung tien cho K cat vao tui \                                                                                                                       r

xach bang da mau nau K deo tren ngubi va dua bich thuoc la cho K treo len nioc 6 ba ga xe mo to, con T mb cop xe de 02 bo tai nghe khdng day vao. Sau do, K chb T chay ra dubng N, khi den mot con hem vang ngubi (khong xac dinh duoc dia diem), T va r      x        r                                                r              r                                                   \

K dung xe lai, mang sb tien lay trom trong heo dat ra dem duoc 7.500.000 dong, T dua tien cho K cat lai vao tui xach bang da mau nau, roi ca hai nhanh chong roi di. Den khoang 09 gib sang ngay 09/01/2023 thi anh T5 phat hien bi mat trom tai san nen den Cbng an Pl, thanh pho S trinh bao sir viec.

Sau khi lay trom tai san tai Quan an gia dinh 168 xong thi den khoang 03 gib cung ngay T va K dieu kliien xe chay tren dubng Quoc 16 80 hubng ve huyen L, khi chay den Quan ca phe Van Hl ngu tren dubng Q, ap P, xa T, thanh pho S, tinh Dong Thap do anh Te Ngoc C lam chu, T phat hien quan co khoa cbng rao, nhung ben trong r                                                          -                                                               ⁹     '

khong nhin thay ngubi trong giu. T keu K dung xe lai de T vao trong quan lay trom may vi tinh mang ve nha su dung, nen K dau xe b ben hong quan dung chb. T lach vao khe ho cua hang rao vao ben trong quan, den quay tiep tan thao lay day cap va man hinh may vi tinh nhan hieu Samsung, mau den mang ra de tren via he noi K r                                      '                    _        ^r

dang dau xe va dua day cap cho K mb cop xe mo to cat vao, T tiep tuc quay vao ben trong quan thao lay 01 dau CPU may vi tinh nhan hieu Super Pro, mau den mang ra, z        9                                                                                                      r                  \

vira den cbng rao thi bi lire luong Cbng an thanh pho S di tuan tra phat hien lap bien ban bat ngubi pham toi qua tang. K nhin thay lire luong Cbng an tuan tra di den nen 9                                                                                                                            '

nd may xe bo chay khoang 100 met thi bi bat giu.

Co quan Canh sat dieu tra Cbng an thanh pho S da tam giu:

- 01 man hinh may vi tinh nhan hieu Samsung, mau den, da qua sir dung, chua kiem tra chat luong ben trong.

• - 01 dau CPU may vi tilth nhan hieu Super Pro, ntau den, da qua sir dung, chua kiem tra chat luong ben trong.

• - 01 soi day cap man hinh may vi tilth.

• - 01 cuon bang keo den, da qua sir dung.

y                                                  y           y

• - 02 tua-vit bang kim loai co tay cam bang nhira.

• - 01 xe mo to nhan hieu SHUZA, so loai 110, mau den-xam, so killing RLPWCHBUM7B002643, so may VUMYG150FMH167643, bien so 68P2-0732,

9                          '

da qua su dung, chua kiem tra chat luong ben trong cua Vo Ba K.

• - 01 dien thoai di dong nhan hieu Nokia, mau den-bac, da qua sir dung, chua nr

kiem tra chat luong ben trong cua Nguyen Van T.

• - So tien 1.515.000 dong trong tui quan cua Nguyen Van T.

• - 01 cai tui xach bang da mau nau cua Vo Ba K, ben trong co so tien 15.116.000 dong.

• - 01 bo tai nghe nhan hieu AirPods Pro mau trang.

• - 01 bo tai nghe nhan hieu Soundpeats mau den.

• - 01 con heo dat mau hong bi vo.

• - 06 doan video dirge trich xuat tir cac camera giant sat cua Q an gia dinh 168 va Quan ca phe Van Hl ghi nhan hinh anh T va K thirc hien hanh vi tront cap tai san vao ngay 09/01/2024, duoc liru giu trong 02 USB.

Doi vdi 01 bich nylon mau den ben trong co khoang 35 goi thuoc la (gom yr   9

nhieu nhan hieu) K da lain roi mat khi bi lire luong Cong an truy dudi (khong rd d dau), nen khong thu hoi duoc. Qua dieu tra, bi hai Nguyen Le Duy T5 xac dinh bich nylon dung khoang 35 goi thuoc la noi tren da qua han sir dung, anh T5 dinh dem bo di, hien tai san tren khong thu hoi duoc, khong con gia tri su dung, nen anh T5 yeu cau khong dinh gia doi vdi tai san nay.

Tai cac Ket luan dinh gia tai san so 07/KL-HDDGTS ngay 12/01/2024 va so 08/KL-HDDGTS ngay 22/01/2024 cua Hoi dong dinh gia tai san trong to tung hinh sir thanh pho S, tilth Dong Thap ket luan:

• - 01 bo may vi tilth de ban gom: man hinh hieu S2, mau den va dau CPU hieu

y                                                                                          9

Super Pro ntau den (da qua sir dung, thu hoi dirge). Gia tri dinh gia tai thdi diem dinh gia ngay 09/01/2024 la 2.700.000 dong.

• - 01 bo tai nghe hieu Soundpeats ntau den, da qua sir dung, thu hoi duoc. Gia tri dinh gia tai thdi dient dinh gia ngay 09/01/2024 la 316.667 dong.

• - 01 bo tai nghe hieu AirPods Pro mau trang, da qua sir dung, thu hoi duoc. Gia tri dinh gia tai thdi dient dinh gia ngay 09/01/2024 la 130.000 dong.

• - 01 con heo dat, mau hong, da qua sir dung, thu hoi dirge Gia tri dinh gia tai thdi diem dinh gia ngay 09/01/2024 la 15.000 dong.

Tong gia tri tai san bi chiem doat tai Quan an gia dinh 168 la 7.976.667 dong, gia tri tai san bi chiem doat tai Quan ca phe Van Hl la 2.700.000 dong. Tong cong la 10.676.667 dong.

Tai cac Ket luan giam dinh so 337/KL-KTHS, 338/KL-KTHS cung ngay 25/3/2024 cua Phong KI Cong an tinh D ket luan:

• - Khdng phat hien dau vet cat ghep, chinh sua noi dung hinh anh ddi vdi 06 tep video trong mau can giam dinh.

• - Da trich xuat hinh anh co lien quan tdi vu viec tir 06 tep tin video trong mau can giam dinh ra ban anh.

• - Doi vdi 01 man hinh may vi tinh nhan hieu Samsung, mau den; 01 dau CPU may vi tinh nhan hieu Super Pro, mau den; 01 soi day cap man hinh may vi tinh, tat ca da qua sir dung, clnra kiem tra chat hrong, Co quan Canh sat dieu tra Cong an thanh pho S da hoan tra cho anh Le Ngoc C nhan lai xong.

• - Ddi vdi 01 bo tai nghe nhan hieu AirPods Pro mau trang; 01 bo tai nghe nhan hieu Soundpeats mau den; 01 con heo dat mau hong bi vd va so tien 7.515.000 dong, Co quan Canh sat dieu tra Cong an thanh pho S da hoan tra cho anh Nguyen Te Duy T5 nhan lai xong.

'                                                     a                                                              \             y

• - Doi vdi 02 tua-vit bang kim loai co tay cam bang nhira, 01 cuon bang keo den, tat ca da qua sir dung la tai san cua Vd Ba K, khdng lien quan den vu an, Co quan Canh sat dieu tra Cong an thanh pho S da hoan tra cho Vd Ba K nhan lai xong.

Tai Cao trang so 36/CT-VKSTPSD ngay 23 thang 4 nam 2024, Vien kiem sat nhan dan thanh pho S da truy to bi cao Nguyen Van T ve toi “Trom cap tai san” theo khoan 1 Dieu 173 cua Bo luat Hinh sir; truy to bi cao Vd Ba K ve toi “Trom cap tai san” theo diem g khoan 2 Dieu 173 cua Bo luat Hinh sir.

Tai phien toa, dai dien Vien kiem sat thirc hanh quyen cong to giir nguyen quyet dinh truy to ddi vdi cac bi cao. Sau klii phan tich cau thanh toi pham, cac tinh tiet tang nang, giam nhe trach nhiem hinh sir, de nghi Hoi dong xet xir tuyen bo cac bi cao Nguyen Van T, Vd Ba K pham toi “Trom cap tai san”.

Ve hinh phat:

• - De nghi ap dung khoan 1 Dieu 173, diem s khoan 1 Dieu 51, diem g khoan 1 Dieu 52, Dieu 17, Dieu 58 cua Bo luat Hinh sir, xir phat bi cao Nguyen Van T mire an tir 09 thang den 12 thang til.

• - De nghi ap dung diem g khoan 2 Dieu 173, diem s khoan 1 Dieu 51, diem g khoan 1 Dieu 52, Dieu 17, Dieu 58 cua Bo luat Hinh sir, xir phat bi cao Vo Ba K vdi mire an tir 03 nam den 04 nam til.

Ve hinh phat bo sung: Khong de nghi ap dung.

Ngoai ra, Vien kiem sat cdn de nghi xu ly vat chung, tai san tam giir theo quy dinh phap luat.

Cac bi cao nhan toi, khong co y kien bao chira, tranh luan; xin diroc giam nhe hinh phat.

NHAN DINH CUA TOA AN:

• •

Tren co sb noi dung vu an, can cu vao cac tai lieu trong ho so vu an da duoc tranh tung tai phien toa, Hoi dong xet xu nhan dinh nhu sau:

• [1] Trong qua trinh dieu tra, truy to, cac co quan va ngubi tien hanh to tung da thuc hien dung tham quyen, trinh tir, thu tuc quy dinh cua Bo luat to tung hinh sir. Bi cao khong co y kien hoac kliieu nai ve hanh vi, quyet dinh cua Co quan tien hanh to

r                    r                                                  r                           r                    r

tung, ngubi tien hanh to tung, cac hanh vi to tung, quyet dinh to tung cua cac co r                         '

quan, ngubi tien hanh to tung la dung quy dinh phap luat.

• [2] Tai phien toa, cac bi cao thua nhan toan bo hanh vi pham toi cua minh. Lbi khai cua cac bi cao phu hop vbi lbi khai cua bi hai, ngubi lam chung va cac chung cu khac co trong ho so vu an. Qua do co du co sb xac dinh: Khoang 01 gib 40 phut va khoang 03 gib cung ngay 09/01/2024, tai Quan an gia dinh A, dubng A, Kliom D, Phuong A, thanh pho S, tinh Dong Thap va tai Quan Cl, dubng Q, ap P, xa T, thanh pho S, tinh Dong Thap, Nguyen Van T, Vo Ba K da co hanh vi len lut lay trom so tien 15.000 dong de trong ngan tu, so tien 7.500.000 dong de ben trong con heo bang dat mau hong, 01 bo tai nghe khong day nhan hieu AirPods Pro mau trang, 01 bo tai nghe khong day nhan hieu Soundpeats mau den, tong gia tri tai san la 7.976.667 dong cua vo chong anh Nguyen Le Duy T5, chi Nguyen Thanh T7; lay trom 01 bo may vi tinh de ban tri gia 2.700.000 dong cua anh Le Ngoc C nham muc dich sir dung va tieu xai thi bi lire lirong Cong an thanh pho Sa Dec phat hien, lap bien ban bat ngubi pham toi qua tang.

• [3] Day la vu an co tinh chat dong pham, gian don, cac bi cao khong co sir ban bac, phan cong nhiem vu klii thuc hien hanh vi pham toi. Vai tro cua tung bi cao the hien nhu sau:

[3.1] Bi cao Nguyen Van T la ngubi da thanh nien, co du nang lire chiu trach nhiem hinh su, da co gia dinh va con nlio, le ra phai biet cd gang lao dong, tao ra cua cai vat chat chain lo cho gia dinh, the nhirng do y thuc xem thirbng phap luat, muon co tai san ma khong can bo ra nhieu cong sue lao dong nen bi cao da loi dung dem khuya, vang ngubi len lut chiem doat tai san cua ngubi khac nham vu loi ca nhan. ^r                                                                                        9           r

Trong vu an nay bi cao la ngubi true tiep dot nhap va nha cua cac bi hai de chiem z

doat tai san nen phai chiu trach nhiem vbi vai tro la true tiep thuc hien toi pham, thuc hanh tich circ. Vbi gia tri tai san chiem doat la 10.676.667 dong thi hanh vi cua bi cao du yeu to cau thanh toi “Trdm cip tai san” theo quy dinh tai khoan 1 Dieu 173 Bo luat Hinh sir.

[3.2] Bi cao Vo Ba K cung la ngirbi da thanh nien, cd day du nang lire chiu trach nhiem hinh sir, nhieu lan vi pham phap luat bi ket an, nen bi cao hoan toan nhan thuc dirge hanh vi chiem doat tai san cua nguai khac la sai trai, klii thay bi cao T cd hanh vi len lut chiem doat tai san cua nguai khac thi bi cao chang nhung kliong kliuyen can, ma con bi cao giup sire cho bi cao T bang each giu hang rao de bi cao T z                          9                                         r

thuan lai dot nhap vao nha bi hai, cat giu va kiem tra tai san chiem doat dirge, cung nhu canh gidi cho bi cao T trong qua trinh dot nhap vao nha cua bi hai, do do bi cao phai chiu trach nhiem vdi vai tro dong pham, giup sire tich cue. Vdi 03 tien an bi xet xu ve cac toi pham rat nghiem trong den nay chira dirge xoa an tich, thi lan pham toi nay cua bi cao thuoc trirdiig hgp tai pham nguy hiem dirge quy dinh tai diem g khoan 2 Dieu 173 Bo luat Hinh sir.

Dieu 173 cua Bo Luat Hinh sir quy dinh:

“1. Ngircri nao from cap tai san cua ngircri khac tri gia tir 2.000.000 dong den dircri 50.000.000 dong hoac dircri 2.000.000 dong nhimg thuoc mot trong cac tnrcrng hop sau day, thi bi phat cai tao khdng giam giir den 03 nam hoac phat til tir 06 thang den 03 nam

• 2. Pham toi thuoc mot trong cac trirang hop san day, thi bi phat til tir 02 nam den 07 nam:

a). ...

g. Tai pham nguy hiem

r                  x                                                                 \

• [4] Hanh vi cua cac bi cao da xam pham den quyen so^- huu hap phap ve tai san cua nguai bi hai trai phap luat, lam anh hirong xau den tinh hinh trat tir, tri an a dia phuong. Do do, cac bi cao phai bi xu phat theo quy dinh, nham giao due, ran de va phong ngira chung cho xa hoi.

• [5] Ve tinh tiet tang nang, giam nhe trach nhiem hinh sir va hinh phat:

• - Cac bi cao thuc hien 02 lan chiem doat tai san, moi lan tai san chiem doat deu co gia tri tren 2.000.000 dong nen phai chiu tinh tiet tang nang pham toi nhieu lan quy dinh tai diem g khoan 1 Dieu 52 Bo luat Hinh sir.

• - Trong qua trinh dieu tra va tai phien toa, cac bi cao co thai do thanh khan khai bao, to ra an nan hoi cai, vi vay can ap dung diem s khoan 1 Dieu 51 cua Bo

9                                                                               \

luat Hinh sir de xem xet giam nhe mot phan muc hinh phat ddi vai cac bi cao. r

• - Vai tinh chat muc do hanh vi pham toi ma cac bi cao da thuc hien thi can

z

phai ap dung hinh phat chinli ddi vai cac bi cao la tu co thdi han thi mdi du sire de ran de, giao due va phong ngira chung cho toan xa hoi.

• [7] Cao trang truy to va phat bieu luan toi cua vi dai dien Vien kiem sat tai phien toa la phii hap, dung vai tinh chat, muc do hanh vi pham toi cua cac bi cao.

• [8] Ve trach nhiem dan sir: Cac bi hai da nhan lai duac tai san va khong co yeu cau gi. Rieng doi vai so thuoc la (khoang 35 goi, nhieu nhan hieu) bi mat, khong thu hoi duac va con heo dat mau hong bi va, anh T5 va chi T7 khong yeu cau cac bi

y                                                                                              F

cao boi thuong nen khong xem xet giai quyet.

• [9] Ve xu ly vat chung va tai san tarn giu:

• - Doi vai 01 xe mo to nhan hieu SHUZA, so loai 110, mau den-xam, so khung RLPWCHBUM7B002643, so may VUMYG15OFMH167643, bien so 68P2-0732, da qua sir dung, chira kiem tra chat lirong ben trong cua Vo Ba K la plnrong tien K va T sir dung khi thirc hien hanh vi pham toi, can tich thu nop ngan sach Nha nirac.

F                                                       y

• - Ddi vai 01 cai tiii xach bang da mau nau cua Vo Ba K la cong cu K su dung khi thirc hien hanh vi pham toi, khong co nhieu gia tri can tich thu tieu huy.

• - Doi vai 01 dien thoai di dong nhan hieu Nokia, mau den-bac, da qua su dung, chua kiem tra chat luong ben trong va so tien 1.500.000 dong cua Nguyen Van T, so tien 7.616.000 dong cua Vo Ba K khong lien quan den vu an, can tiep tuc quan ly de dam bao viec thi hanh an.

F                                                                                     F

• - Doi vai 06 doan video dirac trich xuat tir cac camera giam sat cua Q an gia dinh 168 va Quan ca phe Van Hl ghi nhan hinh anh T va K thirc hien hanh vi trom cap tai san vao ngay 09/01/2024 duac lini giu trong 02 USB la vat chung cua vu an,

\            r                                                              y                                                                                f

can tiep tuc bao quan lim ho sa lam chung cu giai quyet vu an.

• [10] Ve an phi: Cac bi cao chiu an phi hinh sir so tham theo quy dinh.

Vi cac le tren,

QUYET DINH:

• 1. Can cu khoan 1 Dieu 173; diem s khoan 1 Dieu 51; diem g khoan 1 Dieu 52; Dieu 17, Dieu 58 cua Bo luat Hinh sir:

Tuyen bo: Bi cao Nguyen Van T pham toi “Trom cap tai san”.

Xu phat: Bi cao Nguyen Van T muc an 01 (mot) nam tu. Thai han til tinh tir ngay 09/01/2024 (ngay tarn giu).

• 2. Can cu vao diem g khoan 2 Dieu 173; diem s khoan 1 Dieu 51; diem g khoan 1 Dieu 52; Dieu 17, Dieu 58 cua Bo luat Hinh sir:

Tuyen bo: Bi cao Vo Ba K pham toi “Trom cap tai san”.

Xir phat: Bi cao Vo Ba K mire an tir 02 (hai) nam 06 (sau) thang til. Thai han til tinh tir ngay 09/01/2024 (ngay tarn giu).

• 3. Ve trach nhiem dan sir: Da giai quyet xong.

  
  
  

  - Tich thu nop Ngan sach Nha nude: 01 (mot) xe mo to hieu SHUZA mau den bien so 68P2-0732, so may VUMYG15 OFMH167643, so khung RLPWCHBUM7B002643, so loai 110, da qua su dung chua kiem tra chat luqng ben trong (ben ngoai xe khong co bung, da bi hu hong).

  
  
  
  
  

- Tiep tuc quan ly:

9

+ 01 (01) dien thoai hieu Nokia, mau den-bac, da qua su dung, chua kiem tra r                                                                                                                                                                                             r

chat luqng ben trong (duqc niem phong trong tui phong bi ma so: NS4.2029539) cua Nguyen Van T.

+ Tien Viet Nam: 1.500.000 dong cua Nguyen Van T.

+ Tien Viet Nam: 7.616.000 dong cua Vo Ba K.

De dam bao thi hanh an cho cac bi cao.

(Hien Chi cue Thi hanh an dan su dang quan ly theo bien ban giao nhan vat chung ngay 16/5/2024)

• - Luu ho sex vu an: 06 doan video duqc trich xuat tu cac camera giam sat cua Q an gia dinh 168 va Quan ca phe Van Hl ghi nhan hinh anh T va K thuc hien hanh vi trom chp tai san vao ngay 09/01/2024 duqc luu giu trong 02 USB.

6. Ve an phi: Ap dung Dieu 136 Bo luat To tung hinh su Dieu 23 Nghi quyet so 326/2016/UBTVQH14 ngay 30/12/2016 cua Uy ban Thubng vu Quoc hoi quy dinh ve muc thu, mien, giam, thu, nop, quan ly va su dung an phi va le phi Toa an.

• - Cac bi cao Nguyen Van T, Vo Ba K moi bi cao phai chiu 200.000 dong an phi hinh su su tham.

Cac bi cao co quyen khang cao trong han 15 ngay ke tu ngay horn nay tuyen \                                                                   A                                      \

an. Rieng bi hai, ngucn co quyen lqi, nghia vu lien quan vang mat, co quyen khang 9                                                                                                   r

cao trong thbi han 15 ngay ke tu ngay nhan duqc ban an hoac niem yet ban an.

Nffi nhan'.

• - Toa an nhan dan tinh DT;

• - VKSND TP Sa Dec;

• - Cong an TP Sa Dec;

• - Chi cue THA TP Sa Dec;

• - So Tu phap;

• - Thi hanh an hinh su;

• - Bi cao;

• - Nhung ngudi tham gia to tung; -LuuVT, TP;

• - Luu ho so.